I have come full circle with Led Zeppelin. Back when I started listening to them, at the age of 14 or 15, I thought it was all about the fourth album. The untitled one. The classic one. The one with "Stairway To Heaven" on it. Later, I became more of a tedious purist and started to believe they never really improved on their debut. Later, that choice started to bore me and I went for the more hardcore and uncompromising second album. But even that was not enough, and soon I was in with the hipster crowd claiming the third album was the one with the best tunes. After which, somewhat inevitably, I realised that it was Physical Graffiti all along, that long, sprawling double album that was as patchy as it was powerful. Physical Graffiti was the cool choice. Now, though, I have come full circle.
The thing about Led Zeppelin is that the music worked despite limitations. They stole their riffs from old blues musicians (or perhaps 'appropriated' is the right word?) They wrote inane Tolkien-lite lyrics (Ian Anderson once claimed that with his lyrics and Led Zeppelin's music they could be a great rock'n'roll band). They had a singer who could be obnoxious without even trying too hard (and sometimes he did try very, very hard). And yet, in spite of everything, they were among the very best. Jimmy Page was perhaps the greatest guitar player ever. They were all superior musicians, in fact, and the music oozed so much power and conviction they could almost trick you into believing "The Ocean" was a great song. They were so good, actually, that George Harrison once wanted to join them.
9. Coda (1982)
This is by no means a controversial opinion. Coda was a bad album that was only released to fulfil contractual obligations. What saves it (kind of) is that it was not even a proper studio LP, but just a collection of outtakes from various points of the band's career. And they were all outtakes for a reason; there is not a single song here that would have improved an album they were culled from. Coda is plodding and uninspired, with only a couple of flashes of goodness (not even greatness). "Poor Tom" is a decent folk tune from Led Zeppelin III sessions, "We're Gonna Groove" is an okay cover and "Bonzo's Montreau" is an entertaining drum solo - but its only achievement, really, is that it is better than "Moby Dick".
Best song: "Poor Tom"
8. Presence (1976)
I have never felt comfortable saying that Presence is the worst Led Zeppelin album (nobody counts Coda, do they?). It features a famous Hipgnosis cover. It opens with the band's greatest song. It ends with a classic epic ballad. According to Jimmy Page (never trust an artist when they speak about their own work), this was the band at their peak. However, there's just no getting away from it: Presence is a bit of a mess. Yes, "Achilles Last Stand" is an awe-inspiring epic that never gets boring for a second during its ten and a half minutes. And yes, the sprawling, bluesy "Tea For One" is a worthy successor of "Since I've Been Loving You". I will also admit that "Nobody's Fault But Mine" succeeds through sheer force and oomph. But that's it, really. The rest ranges from awful to mediocre cock rock, and at some point you will be excused to think the shivers that went down your spine at the start of "Achilles Last Stand" were just an illusion.
Best song: "Achilles Last Stand"
7. In Through The Out Door (1979)
While the reputation of Led Zeppelin's last album (nobody counts Coda, do they?) has never been especially great, it has always struck me as a very solid release. There are no embarrassments here, the kind you could expect from a 60s band approaching the 80s. "In The Evening", while overlong, features a timeless riff. The piano-based "South Bound Suarez" (written by Plant and John Paul Jones) is a lot of fun. The playful "Fool In The Rain" is hardly a triumph (the fast tropical part in the middle does not quite work for me) but the power and the mystique are still there. The country western "Hot Dog" is pure filler, but I love everything that follows. The epic "Carouselambra" is not great but I always find myself enjoying all 10 minutes of it, down to the disco ending. "All My Love" is one of their greatest and most touching ballads (Plant's ode to his son who had recently passed away). And the closing "I'm Gonna Crawl" is an undisputed classic, with a great guitar solo and a true claim to being one of Led Zeppelin's best songs.
Best song: "I'm Gonna Crawl"
6. Led Zeppelin II (1969)
While these days I consider the band's second album to be the weakest of the classic six (the production is muddy and murky and almost hides John Paul Jones' brilliant bass playing), I still think it is essential. Or, rather, parts of it. Led Zeppelin II starts very strongly: "Whole Lotta Love" is an experimental orgasmic rocker ("orgasmic" in every sense of the word, in fact) and "What Is And What Should Never Be" is one of their strongest ballads. "The Lemon Song" is somewhat captivating but it also feels like it was stitched together from a bunch of old blues numbers. Now "Thank You" I've never liked. It starts like it means business but then gets pretentious, boring and generic very quickly (despite, again, great musicianship). In a word - the album is patchy and for every amazing riff-rocker ("Heartbreaker") there is an uneventful drum solo ("Moby Dick") or an old blues cover that sounds like it was recorded under water ("Bring It On Home").
Best song: "Whole Lotta Love"
5. Physical Graffiti (1975)
Physical Graffiti is a story of two halves. It is obviously a powerhouse of an album that offers very little respite (which may be the reason why I have always loved the short instrumental "Bron-Yr-Aur" so much - Page was a brilliant acoustic guitar player). It is one pounding rocker after another, and at some point it becomes a little exhausting (which may be the reason why the second part of this double album has never stuck in my memory and remained one big blur). Still, there is enough great material here to make it worth your while. The slide-guitar infested epic "In My Time Of Dying" is paranoid and gripping. "The Rover" is one of their most effective rockers. And "Kashmir" never loses its mystical, Eastern-tinged power. I just wished there was a little more subtlety to the end of this album.
Best song: "The Rover"
4. Houses Of The Holy (1973)
Their most diverse album and the only one that has a sense of humour. Houses Of The Holy has it all, from reggae to folk rock to funk to majestic balladry to synth-based sinister goth epic. And yet it all sounds like prime Led Zeppelin. The album starts beautifully, with three memorable songs that almost deceive you into thinking this could be their songwriting peak. Sadly, they misfire with the funked up (but mercifully short) "The Crunge" but then quickly recover with the second side which is mostly all great. And that includes, yes, the ridiculous reggae-fied single "D'yer Mak'er" which is criminally catchy and an absolute delight. Still, the following "No Quarter" pretty much destroys everything else here: it is menacing, beautifully built and puts unforgettable images into your head. Those of dark knights, lonely fields and centuries-old Gothic castles. I have always loved that Hipgnosis cover, too.
Best song: "No Quarter"
3. Led Zeppelin III (1970)
I still think sometimes that this is their best album. Melodically, they would never beat the striking folk melodies of "Tangerine", "That's The Way", "Friends", etc. There is also something remarkably unpretentious about Led Zeppelin's third album and besides, I've always loved Jimmy Page the acoustic guitar player. The big classic was, of course, the seven-minute blues epic "Since I've Been Loving You", and deservedly so. It has that smoky late-night vibe that just gets under your skin in the nicest way possible. There's that bubbling intensity, the clever build-up and those beautiful organ runs that hold it all together. But, really, it is all good, with the incredibly murky and unmelodic "Hats Off To (Roy) Harper" being the only real letdown. What a confused and confusing ending to such a special album.
Best song: "Since I've Been Loving You"
2. Led Zeppelin I (1968)
They arrived fully formed. I don't exactly love this one more than the third album, but there is something in me that folds under the pressure of the four song run that starts this album. That stuff is unimpeachable, to the extent where you won't even care who they were ripping off here. They owned these melodies, they made them their own. "Babe, I'm Gonna Leave You" is pure perfection, from the gentle acoustic opening to those classic Robert Plant outbursts that never sound obnoxious or overbearing. The rest of the album can't hope to reach those heights but "Black Mountain Side" is a beautiful acoustic guitar workout from Page, "Communication Breakdown" is a great rock'n'roll explosion and "How Many More Times" is a powerful hard blues epic that brings the whole thing to a close.
Best song: "Babe, I'm Gonna Leave You"
1. Led Zeppelin IV (1971)
Well, it was always the fourth one, wasn't it?
While not perfect (Led Zeppelin never made a perfect album, and if I had to put a number on it, I would say this one gets a "9.5"), the Untitled LP is still the one. Somehow it all came together in 1971, and the usually uneven songwriting matched the consistently excellent musicianship. So what keeps it from being perfect? Two things, really. "Misty Mountain Hop" and "Four Sticks" - but even those are good driving rock songs (if a little oversimplistic). And as for the rest of it... well, this is some of the greatest rock music in existence.
Best song: "Going To California" (I mean, not really, but come on)